Das Dilemma, wieso zwar jeder Gläubige Gott als gut bezeichnet, im selben Satz jedoch sagt, dass man über Gott nicht richten soll, wird hier bei Daylight Atheism erläutert:

The logical contradiction between these positions never seems to occur to them; for what is saying “God is good” if not an ethical evaluation of God? How could we possibly call him good unless we’ve judged the morality of his actions and decided that they are in accord with what we call goodness? But if we have the ability to do that, then we necessarily also have the ability to judge his actions as evil. On the other hand, if God is not within our ability to judge, then we have no right to say either that he is good or that he is evil. After all, we’re not in a position to judge! In such a case, we could only say that God is morally ambiguous, or amoral, or that we don’t know whether he is good or not. One cannot have this both ways.¹

1. daylight atheism – On God’s Goodness [↩]